ANI Media v. OpenAI leaves unresolved a logically prior question to copyright use - when may publicly accessible material be lawfully extracted for AI systems? This article argues that Indian law now reflects opt-out reasoning but no opt-out regime. Drawing on Section 43(b) of the Information Technology Act and a twenty-four-domain RightSignal audit, it proposes a purpose-specific framework based on technical conduct, declared function, communicated scope, and collection within scope, distinguishing public accessibility from unrestricted permission.